Tag: 1999 constitution

  • Nigeria at 65: Is Our Constitution Helping or Failing Us?

    Nigeria at 65: Is Our Constitution Helping or Failing Us?

    By Sebastine Chukwuebuka Okafor, Ph.D.

    On the first of October 1960, Nigeria became an independent state and adopted the Independence Constitution, discarding the Lyttleton Constitution of 1954, which had earlier established federalism in the country. Prior to independence, Nigeria had operated under five other constitutions: Sir Frederick Lugard’s Constitution of 1914, the Clifford Constitution of 1922, the Richards Constitution of 1946, the Macpherson Constitution of 1951, and the Lyttleton Constitution of 1954. Each of these shaped the foundation of Nigeria’s political journey.

    These constitutions introduced various changes in the way Nigerians lived together and managed national affairs. The 1914 framework brought about amalgamation. The 1922 Clifford Constitution introduced elective principles in Lagos and Calabar. The Richards Constitution of 1946 ushered in regional representation. The Macpherson Constitution of 1951 expanded regional autonomy and exhibited federal tendencies. The Lyttleton Constitution of 1954 then brought Nigeria closer to full federalism before independence arrived.

    After independence, Nigeria entered another phase of constitutional experimentation. The Republican Constitution of 1963 replaced the Queen of England with a Nigerian President as Head of State. The 1979 Constitution introduced a presidential system of government modeled after that of the United States. The 1989 Constitution was drafted but never fully implemented due to the political crisis following the annulled June 12 election. The short-lived 1993 Constitution also failed to stand the test of time. Finally, the 1999 Constitution ushered Nigeria into the Fourth Republic, which remains in effect today.

    When we consider both the pre- and post-independence documents, it becomes clear that Nigeria has had a total of eleven constitutions: 1914, 1922, 1946, 1951, 1954, 1960, 1963, 1979, 1989, 1993, and 1999. Each came with its own strengths and weaknesses, reflecting the country’s ongoing search for a system that suits its diverse population.

    Today, many Nigerians are asking whether the 1999 Constitution is truly serving the people. Some argue that it has helped stabilize democracy since 1999 by ensuring regular elections and continuous civilian rule without military interference. Others contend that it remains flawed, retaining too much influence from the military era and lacking a truly people-centered foundation.

    One of the Constitution’s strengths is its clear definition of the separation of powers among the executive, legislature, and judiciary. It also guarantees fundamental rights for citizens and provides a framework for elections through INEC, elements that have helped democracy endure for over two decades.

    However, its weaknesses cannot be ignored. The Constitution grants excessive power to the Federal Government, leaving states with limited control over resources and security. The immunity clause has often been abused by leaders who use it to shield themselves from accountability. Many Nigerians also believe that local governments lack true autonomy under the current structure.

    Another concern is the rigidity of the Constitution. For a law meant to serve the people, it is far too difficult to amend. Even when changes are made, as in 2010, 2011, 2018, and 2023, many feel these amendments fall short of addressing the country’s core governance and development challenges.

    So, is the Constitution working or not? In some respects, yes, it has kept Nigeria under uninterrupted civilian rule for 26 years. But in many other ways, it falls short, as too many citizens still feel excluded from the system, and too many everyday issues remain unresolved under the current constitutional framework.

    What Nigeria needs is not just another piecemeal amendment, but a more inclusive process where the people have a stronger voice in shaping the rules that govern them. Until that happens, the Constitution will remain a blend of progress and problems, leaving the question of whether it is truly working open for debate.

  • Bakare: 1999 constitution is a lopside sham, the Nation needs restructure

     

     

    Serving Overseer of The Citadel Global Community Church (CGCC) and Convener, Save Nigeria Group (SNG), Pastor Tunde Bakare, has described the 1999 constitution as draconian and lopsided sham which must be torn down for the country to move forward.

     

    In his State of the Nation address tagged: “The Black Box of Nigeria’s Politics,” which was relayed from his Lagos church, yesterday, he said if President Muhammadu Buhari does not tear the constitution down and push for restructuring of the nation, not only would history record that he failed to rise to the occasion, he would have squandered a great opportunity.

     

     

     

    He said many of those who say Nigeria’s unity is non-negotiable pay lipservice to a version of unity that serves their selfish interests.

     

    “Our founding fathers signed a contract in 1960 detailing the terms and conditions of our union or unity following a series of negotiations. This contract was then updated in 1963 following due consultations. While the 1999 Constitution opens with the preamble: “We the people,” ‘we, the people of Nigeria’ were neither duly consulted nor did we accept the conditions under which we are now being governed. How, then, can anyone hypocritically insist that our unity is non-negotiable? Did we not negotiate it in 1960 and 1963?

     

    “The majority of the champions, promoters and supporters of the “our unity is non-negotiable” slogan pay lipservice to a version of unity that serves their selfish interests. What they are insisting on, in reality, is that ‘our disunity is non-negotiable’ and that we must be forced to live together irrespective of the inherent dysfunctionality of the terms and conditions. The continued insistence on altering the set rules in the midst of our spirited game of national development, and the subsequent imposition of a draconian and lopsided concoction of a constitution in 1999 is the most inhibiting, corrosive spanner thrown into the wheel of our national unity and faith, peace and progress, from that time until now. I am fully persuaded, as are many fellow compatriots within and outside the shores of Nigeria, that the 1999 Constitution, whether as amended or to be further amended by the National Assembly is nothing more than a glorified death certificate.”

     

     

     

    Pastor Bakare added that what the country needed ws a geo-political structure that would provide an enabling environment for every zone to maximise its geo-economic opportunities and potentials under a strong country and that this can be achieved by a pragmatic approach to restructuring Nigeria rather than by mere zoning of the presidency.

     

    “Once upon a time, the Berlin walls separated Eastern Germany from Western Germany until President Ronald Reagan in his indomitable manner spoke lucidly on live television to the president of the then Soviet Union.

     

    “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall. Mr Gorbachev eventually did, and Germany is better off for it today. In the same spirit, I say to President Muhammadu Buhari. ‘Mr President, stop passing the buck to the National Assembly. Tear down this inhibiting concoction of a constitution; tear it down so we can build a truly great nation.’ This is one enduring legacy your administration can still secure before your time in power draws to a close. If you do, present and unborn generations of Nigerians will remember you for it and write your name in gold when the history of this period is written. If you don’t, history will record that you failed to rise to the occasion and squandered a great opportunity.”

     

    He warned that those clamouring and waiting for genuine change to happen through the forthcoming 2023 presidential election without first insisting that the “imposed sham of a constitution must be torn and discarded are merely putting the cart before the horse. This is nothing but a prescription for retrogression. No tangible progress can ever be made by such an exercise in futility. It would be tantamount to building a superstructure on a faulty or shaky foundation.”

     

     

     

    Source: www.sunnewsonline.com

  • The ongoing public hearing On the 1999 Constitution Review

    .

     

    THE ongoing public hearing on the amendment of the 1999 Constitution continued across the country on Thursday with a warning by the Pentecostal Fellowship of Nigeria to the Senate to avoid surreptitious moves by some groups to introduce Sharia law to the South-West region through the on-going constitution review.

     

    The President of PFN, Bishop Wale Oke, said in a statement issued by his Media Office on Thursday that the move was capable of adding to the numerous problems facing the country.

     

    He urged the Senate not to succumb to such agitation which he said was capable of further plunging the country into major religious crisis.

     

    He said, “The problems confronting our nation are enormous than wanting to create more. Sharia law is alien to our culture of religious existence in the South-West. As such, nobody should through any subterfuge, bring it in to cause crisis.”

     

    S’South demands power devolution, state police

     

    In Rivers State, the South-South geopolitical zone demanded devolution of power, resource control and creation of additional states in the area.

     

    The hearing organised for Rivers, Akwa Ibom and Cross River states by the Senate Ad-hoc Committee on Amendment of the Constitution, chaired by Senator George Sekibo, had many stakeholders from various ethnic nationalities in attendance.

     

    The host, Nyesom Wike, who declared the hearing open, said there was urgent need for the amendment to produce a people’s constitution that would guarantee devolution of powers, fiscal federalism, creation of state police, as well as strengthening of the electoral system.

     

    Wike, who was represented by his deputy, Dr Ipalibo Banigo-Harry, said the amendment must allow the states to create and sustain local government councils and ensure reduction of the cost of governance at both federal and state levels.

     

    “Nigerians need a constitution that will give them a true sense of belonging, secure and advance their wellbeing and enable their children to aspire to actualise their potential for any office without discrimination,” he said.

     

    On its part, the Akwa Ibom State Government said the challenges plaguing the country was deeply rooted in the ground norm that held various parts of the country together.

     

    Represented by the Director of Litigation, Bassey Ekanem, he said the Federal Government was completely overburdened, adding that the state had listed about 25 matters in the exclusive list that should be transferred to the concurrent list.

     

    Earlier in his remarks, the Deputy President of the Senate, Senator Ovie Omo-Agege, who was represented by Senator George Sekibo, representing Rivers East, disclosed that zonal public hearing on the 1999 Constitution review adopted the bottom to top approach in order to entertain the views of stakeholders at the zonal level.

     

    Meanwhile, the National Vice-President, PFN, Apostle Zilly Aggrey, said the country needed a brand new constitution, even as he expressed fears that the ongoing selective amendment might end in futility.

     

     

    Aggrey stated, “The PFN is firmly of the view that the review process by amending a segment of the constriction may just be another exercise in futility that cannot meet the expectations of the people.”

     

    S’West seeks fiscal federalism

     

    Also, the Lagos zonal constitution hearing entered Day Two on Thursday with stakeholders reiterating calls for a total review of the constitution to reflect fiscal federalism; implementation of the Child Rights Act and Disability Act in states, local government autonomy, judicial autonomy and creation of state police.

    A Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Wole Olanipekun, represented by his son, advocated that judicial outcome be respected and adhered to so that the common man could feel protected and their rights protected.

     

    According to him, the Electoral Act should be amended to allow governorship election cases to terminate at the Supreme Court.

     

    Rights activist, Femi Falana, made a large case for the poor and vulnerable, insisting that it was important to give secession agitators the confidence of peace and inclusion if they must remain.

     

    The lawyer also advocated that the Child Rights Act enacted in 2003, and the Disability Act, be domesticated and implemented in states if the constitution review must make meaning to the common man.

     

     

    Ex-CP declares state police anti-Igbo

     

    There was, however, a mild drama at the Enugu Centre as Ibezimako Aghanya, a retired Commissioner of Police, declared that creation of state police would not be in Igbo interest.

     

    The former Kogi State police commissioner said the Igbo should only support state police when state of origin was removed and replaced with state of residence, adding that “otherwise if state police is created, Igbo will suffer.

     

    Aghanya said, “So what I am saying, if actually we want to create a state police let us first remove state of origin in our constitution and put state of residence. With it an Igbo boy born in Lagos can join Lagos police, an Igbo boy born in Kano can join Kano police and an Igbo boy born in Sokoto can join Sokoto police.”

     

    Southern Borno alleges animals, humans drink from same source

     

    However, the people of Southern Borno in Borno State have lamented that the zone has been marginalised for a very long time, hence their demand for the creation of a state for the zone.

     

    They lamented that despite their contributions to the development of the state, the region had been left to suffer with their people drinking water from the same river with their animals.

     

    They stated these in an interview with journalists on the sidelines of their presentation on Thursday at the Zonal Senate Public Hearing on the amendment of the 1999 Constitution held in Bauchi on why they are agitating for Savannah State.

     

    Captain Ibrahim Mshelia of the Southern Borno Global Initiative lamented that their children were learning under leaking classrooms while some studied mathematics on bare ground using their fingers.

     

    He said, “Some people have no drinking water; they drink water with animals. The same river that feeds them water for everything is the river that they feed their animals with. But in Maiduguri, there are taps, our children are still sitting on stones, inside the  buildings; you can see the sun, and when it is raining, they go under trees. They are sitting on the stone.”

     

     

    Source: www.punchng.com1999